Scott McTominay
Napoli · Midfielder · Scotland · 699 min
Ballity Verdict
What makes this player special?
Scott McTominay is the kind of midfielder coaches build possession around. At Napoli, his real value is not goals or highlight assists — it is how cleanly he moves the team from safe zones into dangerous ones, almost never giving the ball away cheaply. Ballity's clearest read is box crasher: he controls games more than he decides them.
What separates McTominay from ordinary specialists is breadth inside a coherent family: credible as box crasher, and still trustworthy when asked to step toward carrier. That is versatility with a purpose — not a random scatter of average roles.
On the pitch he has actually been used as CM (#8) / AM (#10). That matters: skill-set breadth is one thing; demonstrated deployment is another. McTominay's authenticity claim starts from those minutes, not from a role board alone.
Sample size still limits how hard you can push the conclusions. The football idea is clear; the confidence should stay honest until a fuller season of minutes confirms it.
Why Ballity says this
- Midfield / role totality: box crasher, carrier, deep-lying playmaker
- Shown minutes: CM (#8) / AM (#10)
- No major weakness flags in the current profile
Receipts
- · Player Profile
- · Role Breadth
- · Deployment authenticity
- · Sample · limited
Position
Midfielder
Appearances
8
Great+ roles
1
Age
29
Preferred foot
Right
Height
193 cm
Ballity insights
Peer context vs midfielders — how often they get the ball and what they do with it. Separate from role tiers above.
Usage rate
Share of team touches (non-GK) among midfielders with match data.
35.2% team touches
Peer band · Minimal
Pool percentile
13.1%
Also 58.2 touches/90 (season aggregate).
Efficiency
Output quality per action for midfielders.
66 score
Peer band · High
Pool percentile
73.9%
Balance & structural weaknesses
How complete this player is on the position's job board — strengths and holes.
How we define this
Two-way = Great+ on ≥2 complementary axes. One-way = every other route Limited/closed. Weak routes = Average holes on complementary axes.
No Elite/Great axis on this position's job board, so no weakness flag.
Stat profile
Within position peers — percentile shape (not role scores).
Versatility Index
Precise 0–100 score — cross-group breadth (67%) plus within-group depth (33%), quality-scaled by tier. Distinct from the shape card below.
Index
47.7
Breadth 30.2 · Depth 17.5
- ·Fullbacks: Playmaking FB (Good)
- ·Midfielders: Box Crasher (Elite), Carrier (Great), Deep-Lying Playmaker (Good)
- ·Forwards: Poacher (Great), Target Man (Great)
Versatility shape
Coarse directional pattern (Specialist / Dual-threat / Generalist) — not the 0–100 Index above.
Specialist
Great SpecialistDistinct Great+
1 Great+ roles total
Where he plays
Positions with deployment evidence — not statistical guesses.
Natural
Role translations
Where the profile could fit. Tap a position — then see which role style suits it.
Select a position on the pitch to see the best role, alternatives, and evidence.
Role-by-role detail
How each role is scored. Expand a row for a radar of role-shaped stats.
Similar players
Shape match across midfielder roles — cosine similarity of role scores (domestic leagues only). Slot 1 is the best same-league match; the rest are the next closest from the full pool.
Aimar Oroz
Osasuna · La Liga 24/25
Closest roles
CarrierΔ13
Deep-Lying PlaymakerΔ8
Box CrasherΔ30
Carles Aleñá
Deportivo Alavés · La Liga 24/25
Closest roles
- CarrierΔ26
- Deep-Lying PlaymakerΔ20
- Box CrasherΔ46
Pierre-Emile Højbjerg
Olympique de Marseille · Ligue 1
Closest roles
- CarrierΔ6
- Box CrasherΔ19
- Deep-Lying PlaymakerΔ10